Daniel Grand says University Heights officials surveilled and harassed him, and he hopes the high court's ruling in his case opens the courthouse doors for others
Getty Images
United States Supreme Court
When Daniel Grand emailed friends and neighbors to invite them to a minyan at his home in 2021, he never imagined that email would set off a series of events that would trigger surveillance, harassment, antisemitism and ultimately a Supreme Court case.
But five years later, Grand, an Orthodox Jew from University Heights, Ohio, is now the petitioner in a Supreme Court case against his hometown, which he says employed aggressive tactics to block the minyan from taking place. The high court is set to rule on whether Grand has standing to sue or whether he will be required to wait until the city fully adjudicates his zoning petition before engaging in litigation.
Grand said that the situation is still bewildering to him.
“It’s an unbelievable idea that I can’t, to this day, fully get. Why would somebody be so interested in stopping me and just a handful of friends from planning a constitutionally protected class of gathering and assembly and religious prayer?” Grand asked in a recent interview with Jewish Insider. “Why would they want to stop that? What does it do for them?”
He described the campaign against him as “un-American” and attributed it to both a lack of understanding about Orthodox Judaism and to bigotry.
The city’s former mayor, whom Grand said led the campaign against the minyan, has “not been willing to understand. The differences in his mind, seemingly, just make it that it’s intolerable to him to have people who are different than he is in outlook and worldview and maybe religious expression.”
“I absolutely think that it’s a bunch of bigots that did this thing to me,” Grand continued. “Whether they hate Jews in their heart? God knows into the hearts of men. I can’t profess to know that, but I don’t think he was very kind to me.”
Both the city and its former mayor previously declined to comment on the case given the pending litigation.
Grand said that, when he first sent out the invitation, he did not give it much thought. Then, he said, the campaign began: an “urgent” voicemail from the mayor, as well as a cease-and-desist that was both hand-delivered and emailed. Grand said he initially sought to explain to the then-mayor that the gathering would have no more impact than inviting some friends over to watch a game.
But he said he was told by the mayor that he needed to apply for a permit to designate his home as a house of prayer, which the mayor and other city officials led him to believe would be a quick and simple process, not a drawn-out public spectacle.
“I went through their process. I was deceived by him. … The city lied to me, the mayor and the city were dishonest with me,” he said. “They knew I never needed a permit to pray, they conceded that much later after litigation began,” and never made clear to Grand that he would no longer be able to live in his home if the permit was approved. “They knew that. I didn’t.”
He said that he faced hypocrisy from city officials and other residents, who claimed they objected to any religious institution in their neighborhood — despite there being another religious institution with 700 member families a block away from his house.
“We tried … for almost 16 months,” he said, but faced escalating harassment from the mayor and other city officials, whom he said dispatched police, private investigators and his neighbors to surveil him; stopped picking up his trash; issued illegal citations against him; accused him of nonexistent zoning infractions and more over the course of more than a year.
“I tried to negotiate and work with them while I’m dealing with all this harassment and these violations and all these pursuits,” he said. “We wound up filing a lawsuit because this was really relentless and misguided and really evil behavior on part of that administration. And lo and behold, the lawsuit sort of started to make them take a step back because they felt that perhaps they were being observed a little bit more.”
Though he filed his petition to the Supreme Court as a pro se defendant, meaning without a lawyer, Grand downplayed his own role, emphasizing that it was a “group effort” built upon “people, concepts, ideas” and other past briefs that he was able to model.
Jonathan Gross, Grand’s attorney who has been with him from the start of the case, said, “It was so obvious as we now see that the city was wrong … and yet the district court got it wrong and the appellate court got it wrong. We’re one in 10,000 cases that makes it to the Supreme Court, but if Daniel didn’t get accepted by the Supreme Court, then that’s it.”
Grand offered vociferous thanks to his lawyers at every level who have “all been really instrumental” as well as all of the different groups, members of Congress, states and the solicitor general who filed briefs with the Supreme Court in support of Grand.
“I’m very, very touched and appreciative,” he said.
He said he’s “encouraged” and “proud” that the Supreme Court felt the petition merited a response and national attention, and hopes that it can “potentially serve as a roadmap for other individuals who’ve experienced similar traumatic episodes, such as I, and had their rights paused at the courtroom gate,” opening up legal avenues for redress for others who have not been able to bring suit for procedural reasons.
If the court rules his way, “a law director in a little town is going to say, ‘Well you better let them do what they’re doing because now they could probably just go and sue right away,’” Grand predicted. “I think it could be cited a lot, and that, really, to me, is the ultimate outcome that I would love to see happen with the Supreme Court.”
Gross, his attorney, said that there are likely similar cases happening across the country on a daily basis with plaintiffs who don’t have the resources or knowledge to file suit and who never receive any national media or advocacy attention. He said that even a victory for Grand at the Supreme Court won’t fully rectify that issue.
“We hope [the case] highlights that we have a serious problem that’s going on all over the country and there’s really no efforts to reform this,” he said.
Daniel Grand is suing the city of University Heights, Ohio, in a case that has attracted attention from the federal government, Republican lawmakers and Jewish groups
Getty Images
United States Supreme Court
The Supreme Court is set to hear a case this winter brought by a man whose hometown sought to block him from holding a minyan in his residence, a case that Jewish community advocates argue could have profound implications for religious Jews as well as those of other faiths.
Daniel Grand, an Orthodox Jewish man, sought to organize a weekly minyan on Saturdays in his home in University Heights, Ohio, because he lives far from any Orthodox synagogue and it was impractical for him to walk to services. But the city issued a cease-and-desist, including a threat of fines or prison time, demanding that he stop holding the services and apply for a permit to operate his home as a synagogue.
Grand applied and paid for the permit and an attorney, but ultimately withdrew the application, in part because he learned he would not be able to continue to live in his home if the permit were granted and he faced what his attorneys described as obstruction by then-Mayor Michael Brennan.
At issue in this case is whether Grand had standing to sue the city before fully seeing through the permitting process; lower courts have ruled that he needed to have the permit rejected before filing suit. Grand, unusually, filed his petition for the Supreme Court to hear his case himself, without a lawyer, at which point the high court took the case up and will hear it on Dec. 9.
Grand’s attorneys argue that the city’s initial decision to block Grand from holding the minyan was sufficient to create standing for him to sue, and that the harm to him has continued since then. The city alleges that Grand is attempting to force the Supreme Court to “serve as a local planning commission” and assess its local zoning ordinances.
Grand alleges, per a brief filed by his lawyers, that he has faced a “torrent of harassment and religious discrimination” and surveillance by the city and Brennan personally.
The City of University Heights declined to comment on pending litigation. Brennan, citing the advice of legal counsel, also declined to comment and referred Jewish Insider to his attorney, who likewise declined to comment.
Upon being asked by another resident to put a stop to the minyan, the brief states, Brennan personally called to tell Grand he was barred from holding “any type of religious gathering” in his house without a permit and threatened criminal charges. Grand’s attorneys allege that Brennan remained personally involved in a campaign to harass him.
Brennan also allegedly turned the hearing for his application into a “public spectacle,” ordered police to monitor Grand’s home for signs of religious gatherings and urged neighbors to do the same. One neighbor installed multiple security cameras recording Grand’s home, footage from which was reviewed by Brennan and city officials, and the city threatened Grand when he attempted to block the cameras.
The city also launched a criminal investigation and charged him with what his attorneys characterize as “spurious” violations, as well as stopping trash pickup from his home.
Some of the public opposition to Grand’s efforts to hold a minyan has appeared overtly antisemitic: One letter to the city about the case complained, “I am not Jewish and I do not want our neighborhood labeled as Jewish.”
The city’s current mayor, Michele Weiss, is the first Orthodox Jewish woman elected mayor anywhere in the United States and the city has the largest concentration of Orthodox Jews in Ohio.
Solicitor General John Sauer, joined by other Justice Department officials including Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon, filed a “friend of the court” brief on behalf of the U.S. government in support of Grand.
It argues that the past precedent has been interpreted and applied incorrectly, and that Grand is eligible to apply for legal relief.
“[The city’s] demands succeeded, leading petitioner to cancel his prayer group and imposing an objectively reasonable chill on religious exercise,” Sauer’s brief continues, further criticizing the permitting process that Grand was compelled to engage in, including paying to hire a lawyer. “So long as respondents’ actions continue to inflict an objectively reasonable chill on petitioner’s religious exercise, he can seek prospective relief today.”
Ten Republican senators and more than 40 GOP House members signed a brief supporting Grand, including House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-LA), Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) and House Judiciary Committee Chairman Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH).
The brief from congressional Republicans highlights Congress’ 2000 passage of the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA), which aims to prevent discrimination in zoning laws against individuals and religious institutions, including to protect private in-home prayer gatherings. They argued that RLUIPA, which Grand alleges the city violated, was written specifically to allow individuals like Grand to file suit.
“This case shows just how far local governments are willing to go in riding roughshod over Free Exercise rights — including putting Mr. Grand, an observant Orthodox Jew, to the choice of being punished for praying in his home without a permit or moving out of his home entirely to obtain the required permit,” the brief reads. “No American should ever be forced to make such a choice. … The Court should reverse and restore the promise of RLUIPA to safeguard the religious liberty of all Americans.”
Numerous Jewish organizations including Agudath Israel of America, the National Jewish Advocacy Center, National Council of Young Israel, Coalition for Jewish Values, the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, the Orthodox Union, the American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists (AAJLJ), as well as groups representing a host of other religions, have filed briefs in support of Grand.
“Where a municipality or other government agency has either zoning laws or other regulatory regimes that allow them enormous, unbridled, standardless discretion to either grant or deny permits for various kinds of activity, there is an enormous risk, well illustrated by this case, that’s going to be weaponized against vulnerable minorities,” Richard Rosen, senior vice president for legal advocacy at the Brandeis Center, told JI.
He alleged that the “evidence is overwhelming that the city acted with antisemitic animus,” pointing to the appeals from neighbors to the mayor and public antisemitic comments by certain residents. Rosen argued that the permitting requirement, in and of itself, represented a violation of the First Amendment that entitled Grand to sue without any further action.
Nathan Diament, executive director of the OU Advocacy Center, told JI that the case raises profound concerns for observant Jews, if municipalities are able to ban any religious gatherings in private homes.
“Just think about an unfortunate situation where somebody is sitting shiva, where you’re not allowed to leave your home as a mourner,” Diament said. “Now we’re going to say, ‘You have to get a permit from the locality in order to have a shiva minyan’? That would be insane.”
Daniel Kaminetsky, general counsel for Agudath Israel, likewise warned that a failure by the court to “correct this wrong” could jeopardize Jews’ ability to pray in the way they see fit.
“Where does it end? Where does it stop? Can the government tell me I can’t have 10 people over for a barbecue and make a bracha?” Kaminetsky said. “That is what we see as being a very slippery slope and a very dangerous path to go down.”
He said that Grand “has been injured in that he has not been able to pray in the way he deems appropriate … and every weekend that goes by is another injury for him because … the city’s not allowing him to do that.”
Kaminetsky argued that there is no compelling city interest in preventing Grand from holding the minyan, and that claims that the minyan would create significant traffic or noise were nonsensical given that it would take place on the Sabbath, during which Orthodox Jews do not drive or use other electronics.
Diament further argued that, if Grand were required to go through a complete permitting process before he could file suit, he could be trapped indefinitely with an unresolved permit application with no legal recourse.
Jewish community advocates supporting Grand highlighted that there are a slew of examples of municipalities using zoning laws to attempt to restrict or prevent Jews from living or worshipping in their communities.
According to Arthur Traldi, chair of AAJLJ’s amicus committee, there’s empirical evidence that Jewish and Muslim communities “are particularly likely to be targeted, to need access to the courts because they want to do something like what Grand was doing — they want to pray at home with their friends.”
He added that Jews and other religiously observant communities “will be watching closely to see what the court decides and how it affects the future of the right to worship freely in your home.”
Agudath Israel filed its brief jointly with groups representing the Catholic and Baptist communities. Kaminetsky said that the joint brief highlights that, while the communities may have different theologies, “we have a lot of common ground … on issues that are common to us that we need to fight for.”
Rosen said that a ruling for Grand might lead other municipalities to reconsider their permitting regimes preemptively, in order to avoid future legal action.
Diament predicted that the Supreme Court is likely to rule in such a way that scales back but does not completely overturn the past precedent that lower courts have said requires Grand to complete the permitting process before suing.
Please log in if you already have a subscription, or subscribe to access the latest updates.






























































Continue with Google
Continue with Apple