RECENT NEWS

NEW YORK STATE OF MIND

Jewish groups’ reaction to NYPD reform highlights Mamdani’s clash with Menin

The UJA-Federation of New York and the American Jewish Committee are working to block the CURB Act, which Mamdani supports and the Council speaker has opposed

Zohran Mamdani, mayor of New York, center left, and Julie Menin, speaker of the New York City Council, right, during an announcement of a handshake agreement on the 2027 budget in the rotunda of City Hall in New York (Michael Nagle/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Two leading Jewish organizations’ response to New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s “disbandment” of the NYPD’s protest management team highlights what insiders described as a ploy by the mayor to embarrass Council Speaker Julie Menin, one of his most prominent political rivals.

Mamdani announced Monday he would roll the terror-fighting functions of the Strategic Response Group into the department’s larger counterterrorism bureau, and shift its civil disorder responsibilities to a new “Patrol Support Division,” officially honoring a campaign pledge to end the SRG, some of whose tactics have been criticized, while making no changes to police headcount. 

The mayor debuted the policy in a double-barreled media hit: an exclusive interview with a local TV station alongside Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch and a short-form video on his official social media channels with Councilmember Chi Osse, a fellow member of the Democratic Socialists of America and sponsor of the anti-SRG Communities United to Reject Brutality Act.

In response, the UJA-Federation of New York and the American Jewish Committee attacked not Mamdani’s policy change but Osse’s legislation, which would go even further by prohibiting the deployment of any specialized unit with crowd-control responsibilities to protests. Mamdani has endorsed the bill while also asserting in the video on Monday his new reforms would “accomplish the key changes” the proposal calls for.

“AJC applauds Commissioner Tisch and the NYPD for their unwavering commitment to protecting Jewish New Yorkers and all New Yorkers,” AJC’s regional director, Andrew Gross, said in a statement to Jewish Insider on Tuesday. “At the same time, we are concerned by the Mayor’s support for the CURB Act, which could put New Yorkers at greater risk. Peaceful protest is a fundamental right, but changes to policing must not come at the expense of public safety or leave communities targeted by antisemitism, intimidation, and violence more vulnerable.”

Gross’ comments echoed an X post from UJA-Federation Monday evening.

“We are deeply concerned about the CURB Act, and Mayor Mamdani׳s support for it,” the civic group wrote. “At a time when New York’s Jewish community is facing unprecedented harassment and violence around synagogues and other communal institutions, the proposed legislation would limit the tools available to the NYPD to keep New Yorkers safe. This moment calls for more protection for our city, not less.”

The comments pointed to a behind-the-scenes struggle, according to sources with knowledge of the City Hall drama who requested anonymity to discuss the situation freely. This fight is not, as some supposed, between Mamdani and Tisch, who in both the TV interview and an internal department email assured anxious observers that nothing substantive about police crowd-control protocol would change — a view insiders said they believe she genuinely holds.

Rather, they argued Mamdani’s real foe is Menin. Superficially eliminating the SRG and announcing it alongside Osse, while simultaneously calling for the passage of the CURB Act, is a gambit to remove hard-left pressure from his own office and place it entirely on the Council speaker.

Moreover, the CURB Act places Menin in an especially awkward position because she has declined to let it come up for a vote despite 27 of the 51 members of the City Council, themselves either allied with the far left or fearful of its ire, signing onto the bill.

Menin’s office did not deny this was the dynamic playing out, but provided a statement asserting that the mayor’s current executive powers over the NYPD would enable him to enact all elements in Osse’s legislation without any Council action at all.

“The administration has the authority to implement any changes it wants to see to the operations and structure of the NYPD without legislative action,” a spokesperson for the speaker said in a statement.

Mamdani’s office refused to answer any questions about its political maneuvering,  instead only forwarding a transcript of the mayor’s remarks at a press conference Tuesday morning in which he again endorsed the CURB Act and called for concerns about its provisions to be worked out “during the legislative process.”

Subscribe now to
the Daily Kickoff

The politics and business news you need to stay up to date, delivered each morning in a must-read newsletter.