Commission studying potential Smithsonian Jewish museum holds first meeting
If approved, the move would make the Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History a part of the Smithsonian Institution
Courtesy
The National Museum of American Jewish History
A congressionally created commission studying the potential transfer of the Weitzman National Museum of American Jewish History in Philadelphia to the Smithsonian Institution held its first meeting on Tuesday, the start of a two-year process to produce recommendations for Congress and the Trump administration on whether to move forward with the merger.
The commission, appointed by congressional leaders, includes Weitzman Chairman Emeritus Philip M. Darivoff, author and historian Dara Horn, Washington Free Beacon publisher Michael Goldfarb, former University of Pennsylvania President Amy Gutmann, former Rep. Kathy Manning (D-NC), The New York Historical President Louise Mirrer, former chairman of the U.S. Commission for the Preservation of America’s Heritage Abroad Paul Packer and presidential historian Tevi Troy.
Darivoff, appointed by House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-NY), and Horn, appointed by Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD), serve as chair and vice chair of the commission, respectively.
Commissioners were sworn in on Tuesday by Sens. David McCormick (R-PA) and John Fetterman (D-PA).
“Jewish American history is American history. It should absolutely be shared now and for generations to come,” Fetterman said. “I’m proud to support this commission in its efforts to bring the Weitzman into the Smithsonian and as the first Pennsylvania-based museum in this iconic American institution.”
Darivoff told Jewish Insider in a joint interview with Horn last week that the Weitzman is the only museum that “seeks to tell the full story of American Jews, the history of American Jews, and their broad contribution to America and to inform the visitors on Jewish history and culture.”
Horn agreed that “this is a time when there’s a new urgency to this topic,” given the “ignorance” about American Jewish history and American Jews today. “I am excited to be part of this process and also delighted that this is a possibility that Congress is taking seriously.”
While the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington is a federal entity, it is not a part of the Smithsonian Institution and, Horn emphasized, there’s more to Jewish life and culture than the Holocaust. The Weitzman, she said, can help change the conversation around the American Jewish story.
“This is about America … and this is an important part of American history that has been very neglected, and also this is about a living Jewish culture and civilization,” Horn continued. “It’s a story that not a lot of Americans have access to.”
Both Horn and Darivoff emphasized that Jewish culture and civilization are deeply entwined through American history over the course of hundreds of years.
The commission is charged with examining whether the Weitzman’s collection would enhance the Smithsonian’s collection — something Darivoff said will require hiring experts to conduct research — whether the Weitzman would be a financial burden or benefit for the Smithsonian and how governance of the museum would be handled if a transfer were completed. Darivoff and Horn emphasized that the commission is not prejudging the process.
Becoming part of the Smithsonian would make the Weitzman’s mission to educate people about Jewish culture, history and contributions to the country and the world part of the federal government’s mission, Darivoff explained, “and that’s a huge injection of momentum and an elevation on the project that the mission is dedicated to.”
He said that becoming part of the Smithsonian can also make the Weitzman a more attractive institution for potential donors of precious artifacts, given the prestige that the Smithsonian carries.
“We’re living in an era where you have a crisis of credibility in institutions, and the Smithsonian is an institution that is associated with serious scholarship, serious history, finding ways to translate that history to be accessible to the public, to be accessible to students,” Horn added. “People who are looking for resources about American Jewish history, people who are looking for ways to make this accessible to a broader audience — it would be a way of putting that history in that place.”
The study comes at a time of turmoil for the Smithsonian as a whole. The Smithsonian’s secretary, Lonnie G. Bunch III, is set to resign at the end of the year as President Donald Trump attempts to assert authority over the historically independent institution.
The administration is reportedly attempting to condition funding to the institution on its compliance with the Trump administration’s priorities and preferred narratives.
Asked whether those developments might factor into the commission’s considerations, Darivoff and Horn emphasized that the commission was appointed in a bipartisan fashion and that the questions it is examining are bigger than any political moment.
Darivoff described the Smithsonian as “one of the great and important cultural and educational institutions in our country” and said it will remain so into the future.
“These are things that come and go in our political life,” Horn said. “Regardless of whether it becomes a Smithsonian institution, the Weitzman is going to continue to be here, and this opportunity to examine this as part of the Smithsonian is really something that’s above the fray because it is a generational opportunity.”
Please log in if you already have a subscription, or subscribe to access the latest updates.

































































Continue with Google
Continue with Apple