The department said universities are ‘hellbent on avoiding public accountability after decades of insatiable greed and disregard for the national interest’
Win McNamee/Getty Images
A person walks past the U.S. Department of Education on March 20, 2025 in Washington, DC.
The Department of Education accused U.S. colleges and universities of attempting to hide their foreign donors from public scrutiny, after the American Association of Universities sued to block the release of a report on foreign donors to U.S. institutions of higher education due out last week.
The department had repeatedly delayed the release of such data under Sec. 117 of the Higher Education Act since this summer, but was poised to release it last Friday, until a federal district court issued a temporary restraining order following a lawsuit by the AAU.
“Now, the ‘premier’ association for American research universities is suing because it is hellbent on avoiding public accountability after decades of insatiable greed and disregard for the national interest,” the Department of Education said in a statement. “Americans deserve transparency about the billions flowing from overseas to U.S. campuses, and we will fight AAU in court to deliver it.”
District of Columbia District Judge Tanya Chutkan temporarily halted the release, expressing concern that the disclosure would expose individual donors to scrutiny in perpetuity, potentially jeopardizing the safety of donors in politically repressive countries.
The AAU has argued that disclosure would “chill the lawful generosity” that supports U.S. campuses, went against past written assurances from the Department of Education to institutions and donors that the information would remain confidential and violated the federal rulemaking process.
“Constitution and Supreme Court precedents protect individuals from compelled public exposure of their charitable associations. Publication would expose donors to harassment, reputational harm, and, in some cases, real danger in their home countries,” the organization said. “It would chill the lawful generosity that supports scholarships, research, and teaching on campuses across the country. And it would signal to every donor and every institution that a federal agency’s written commitment cannot be trusted.”
The Department of Education has not addressed its own reasons for repeatedly delaying the release of the data.
The federal government has previously released top-line data about the amount of foreign funding to U.S. colleges and universities but has not released the specific names of donor organizations, which advocates argue would provide critical transparency about potential malign foreign influence in the United States.
The department said that, in spite of receiving billions in taxpayer funding, universities “were cashing multi-million-dollar checks from malign foreign actors that fund centers and faculty who promote anti-Western ideologies and support partnerships that are designed to export sensitive technology to geopolitical adversaries.”
The department urged Congress to pass the DETERRENT Act, already passed by the House, which would lower the bar for reporting foreign donations and require mandatory reporting for donations from any watch-listed foreign entities or countries such as Iran, China, Russia and North Korea.
Karen Paikin Barall, the chief policy officer of the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law, which filed a Freedom of Information Act request in an attempt to force the release of the transparency report amid the department’s delays and threatened its own lawsuit, said her organization is formulating its own response to the temporary restraining order.
She said that Brandeis is considering its legal options to ensure “the public interest” in transparency is represented, and that it wants to see the restraining order lifted. She argued that there are ways to protect concerns about individual privacy while still providing transparency.
“If these institutions are receiving foreign funding, the public has a legitimate interest in understanding those relationships,” Barall said. “And there are potential implications for research security, academic independence, discrimination, foreign influence and campus antisemitism. … This is fundamentally about transparency and the public’s right to know. You can’t follow the money if you don’t know who’s providing it.”
In a fact sheet, the Department of Education also linked foreign funding to the rise of antisemitism on U.S. campuses, citing data from both the department and outside organizations.
The department also accused members of the AAU of failing to report hundreds of millions in foreign donations and of using the lawsuit to hide relationships with foreign entities on U.S. watch lists from lawmakers and the public.
In the fact sheet, the department said it only intended to release the names of foreign entities, not individual foreign donors, denying the AAU’s assertions that the release could threaten individuals, and said it had briefed AAU on such precautions.
The Brandeis Center called the latest delay, the fifth since July, ‘unacceptable and deeply concerning’
Win McNamee/Getty Images
A person walks past the U.S. Department of Education on March 20, 2025 in Washington, DC.
The Department of Education again delayed a report on foreign funding to U.S. colleges and universities, the fifth such delay since mid-July.
The report under Section 117 of the Higher Education Act was expected to be released Friday. The department announced on Friday that it is again postponing the release, which is now slated to occur on Sept. 25.
The Department of Education did not respond to a request for comment.
The Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law sent a letter and filed a Freedom of Information Act request aiming to force disclosure of the report, the identities of those providing foreign funding and the details of the transactions following the previous delay.
The Brandeis Center blasted the Department over the latest postponement.
“A fifth delay in releasing Section 117 data is unacceptable and deeply concerning. When serious questions are raised about foreign influence on our campuses, Americans deserve to know who is providing this money and whether those financial relationships undermine academic independence, campus policies, compliance with federal law and response to antisemitism,” Karen Paikin Barall, the Brandeis Center’s chief policy officer, said in a statement to Jewish Insider.
She emphasized the need for transparency to understand the relationships between universities and foreign donors and ensure accountability.
“While we commend Secretary [Linda] McMahon for her work to increase transparency around foreign funding, five delays in less than three months have left the American people without critical information,” Barall said. “The Department must release the names of these foreign sources and relevant transaction information as soon as possible.”
The letter from CEO Kenneth Marcus follows a public spat in which Qatar's deputy ambassador accused the group of spreading disinformation about Qatari money in higher education
Bonnie Jo Mount/The Washington Post via Getty Images
Students cross a sky bridge in the temporary campus of Northwestern University in Qater on the Education City campus in Doha, Qatar, on November 2, 2015.
The Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law wrote to Qatari Ambassador to the U.S. Sheikh Meshal bin Hamad al-Thani on Wednesday amid a back-and-forth online, urging the Qatari Embassy to release a full public accounting of its funding to U.S. colleges and universities.
“There is a straightforward way for the Government of Qatar to demonstrate that public accounts of its activities are inaccurate or misleading: full disclosure,” Brandeis Center CEO Kenneth Marcus said in a letter to Al-Thani. “We therefore respectfully ask Qatar to provide a complete public accounting, to the people and the Congress of the United States, of the funding and other financial support that its government, the Qatar Foundation, and other Qatari governmental or government-controlled entities have provided to U.S. colleges and universities.”
Marcus urged that such a disclosure “should identify the recipients and amounts, disclose the agreements governing the funds, and explain what Qatar expected or received in return for its largesse. This should include any financial, academic, or other benefits, as well as any role in university governance, faculty or administrative appointments, academic programs, curriculum, research, public communications, or the operation of overseas campuses.”
Marcus argued that a public disclosure would “serve Qatar’s stated interest in correcting purported misinformation” and allow Congress, the administration, schools and the public to assess the relationships based on firsthand information.
“Qatar has described its support for U.S. higher education as beneficial to both countries,” Marcus said. “If that is so, complete transparency should strengthen Qatar’s position. If particular public allegations are false, the documents will demonstrate that fact.”
The Qatari embassy did not respond to a request for comment.
The letter follows a public exchange on social media between Marcus and Qatar’s deputy ambassador, Hamad Al-Muftah, who claimed that critics of Qatar are engaged in a “coordinated disinformation campaign” to manipulate data on foreign funding in U.S. higher education — the release of which has been repeatedly postponed by the Department of Education — in order to accuse the Qatar Foundation of malign activities.
“Their goal appears to be eliciting reactions from House Education Republicans and, more broadly, spreading disinformation that serves the interests of their controllers,” Al-Muftah asserted.
He posted a diagram that he claimed outlined a network including the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, Brandeis Center and Jewish Insider, as well as op-eds published in The Wall Street Journal and Chicago Tribune, which he claimed is intending to influence Republicans on the House Education Committee to investigate the Qatar Foundation.
Marcus responded in a thread on X, stating that the diagram “identifies no disinformation.”
“My colleagues have also presented evidence in the [Chicago Tribune] concerning the relationship between Qatari funding, foreign influence and anti-Semitism on U.S. campuses. You may not like their conclusions, but disagreement is not disinformation,” Marcus said, adding that Al-Muftah’s language invoked an antisemitic trope.
Al-Muftah responded that “we have zero intention to hide anything. Everyone is fully cooperating with the appropriate authorities to ensure complete transparency.” He also said that Qatar has “observed instances of data manipulation and the amplification of misleading information,” denying any connection between Qatari funding and protests on college campuses.
“Regarding the accusation of antisemitism, I am unclear about its origin and why it has been brought up,” he continued. “I simply presented the facts and observations regarding those involved.”
Al-Muftah also said that Qatar’s only intention is “to provide world-class education to individuals in the region.”
Al-Muftah told another critic that presenting the aggregate totals of Qatari funding to various universities is “misleading.”
“The overwhelming majority of this funding is for the operation of American university campuses in Qatar,” he said. “It pays for the education of students, faculty, facilities, and the day-to-day costs of running those campuses. It is not a blank check to the universities’ U.S. operations, nor is it evidence that Qatar is funding antisemitism or campus protests in America.”
A long-delayed federal report on foreign spending in education is due out on Friday, unless its release is again postponed, for what would be the fifth time.
Please log in if you already have a subscription, or subscribe to access the latest updates.


































































Continue with Google
Continue with Apple