Daily Kickoff
👋 Good Friday morning!
In today’s Daily Kickoff, we look at events surrounding the House vote to remove Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) from the House Foreign Affairs Committee and talk to venture capitalist Lee Moser on the latest edition of the JI “Limited Liability” podcast. Also in today’s Daily Kickoff: Irwin Cotler, Ambassador David Pressman and Joshua Malina.
For less-distracted reading over the weekend, browse this week’s edition of The Weekly Print, a curated print-friendly PDF featuring a selection of recent Jewish Insider and eJewishPhilanthropy stories, including: Tracing his family history in Poland, Emhoff explains his approach to antisemitism; Why Jordan is not embracing the Abraham Accords; Robert Shwartzman is inching his way closer to a Formula One spot; At former SS headquarters in Berlin, European leaders teach the U.S. a lesson on antisemitism; Will Scharf steps up to run for Missouri AG; Three Israeli NGOs in Africa weren’t collaborating. Now they’re working together; Gottheimer, Moskowitz call for select committee on antisemitism; and Alvin Bragg defends plea deal in brazen antisemitic attack. Print the latest edition here.
The House voted yesterday to remove Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) from the House Foreign Affairs Committee for past antisemitic and anti-Israel comments by a party-line vote of 218 to 211. Rep David Joyce (R-OH) voted present. Democrats subsequently appointed Omar to the Budget Committee.
Shortly before the vote, Omar joined a number of her onetime Democratic Jewish critics on a resolution “recognizing Israel as America’s legitimate and democratic ally and condemning antisemitism.” More on the resolution below.
One longtime critic of Omar, Rep. Josh Gottheimer (D-NJ) said in a statement that “removing a Member for having different viewpoints — even ones I strongly oppose — violates the entire basis of our democracy. After all, what if next year, a Member of Congress targets me for my unshakable commitment to the U.S.-Israel relationship?” Gottheimer had been publicly undecided on the vote until yesterday.
Another Democrat who has been critical of Omar, Rep. Jared Moskowitz (D-FL), said after the vote that his “no” vote was intended to “protect the institution” rather than show his support for Omar. He argued that “someone with her record of hateful comments does not belong on the House Foreign Affairs Committee.” The Florida freshman, who succeeded former Rep. Ted Deutch (D-FL) in the South Florida district, also condemned Democrats for previous votes to remove Republicans from their committees, saying, “Democrats opened Pandora’s Box last Congress by removing Republican members from committees. Now, it’s on Democrats to close that box.” Moskowitz was likewise publicly undecided in the days leading up to the vote.
Shortly after yesterday afternoon’s vote, Gottheimer and Moskowitz sent a letter to House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) calling for him to establish a select committee on antisemitism. More below.
King Abdullah II of Jordan met with Jewish leaders in Washington, D.C., yesterday. Those in attendance included Rabbi Marc Schneier, Ted Deutch, Jeremy Ben-Ami, Jonathan Greenblatt, Susie Gelman, Hadar Susskind, Dana Gershon, Betty Ehrenberg, Jason Isaacson, John Hannah and Harriet Schleifer.
Following comments made by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to CNN’s Jake Tapper this week comparing Israel’s proposed override clause to a similar law in Canada — known there as the Notwithstanding Clause — Irwin Cotler, who served as Canada’s justice minister and attorney general, told us that the comparison is “uninformed and misleading.”
“Here’s a country that has exactly this provision — it’s called Canada. Is Canada not a democracy?” Netanyahu said when questioned by Tapper about the proposed override clause that would allow a simple majority of 61 MKs to strike down a Supreme Court ruling.
“The override in Canada is within a Charter of Rights and Freedoms,” Cotler pointed out to JI’s Tamara Zieve. “Here in Israel, it’s outside of a charter of rights and freedoms. The override in Canada is within a federal system,” Cotler added, noting that when he was justice minister and attorney general from 2003-2006, the federal government committed never to invoke the override clause. “So if it is invoked in Canada, it’s invoked only by a province. And therefore it has a limitation in terms of its impact.”
Additionally, Cotler said, in Canada one can only invoke the override for five years. “And the fourth thing is there’s a whole system with regard to checks and balances. You’ve got two Houses of Parliament — the House of Commons and the Senate. There’s a whole series of protections with regard to the override.”
Cotler, who is helping to represent the International Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists, said he raised some of these concerns with MK Simcha Rothman, chairman of the Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee, at a Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs meeting yesterday, and plans to meet privately with the Religious Zionist politician to further discuss the issue.
on the hill
Ilhan Omar joins resolution recognizing Israel as ‘legitimate and democratic ally,’ denouncing antisemitism

Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN), who was removed yesterday from the House Foreign Affairs Committee by a party-line vote, is co-sponsoring a resolution “recognizing Israel as America’s legitimate and democratic ally and condemning antisemitism,” Jewish Insider’s Marc Rod reports. The resolution, announced shortly before the vote, marks a stunning turnaround for Omar, who is one of the most prominent critics of Israel in the House and has repeatedly faced criticism from colleagues on both sides of the aisle for antisemitic and anti-Israel comments — culminating in yesterday’s vote.
In the text: “America’s involvement in the Middle East and alliance with the United States’ legitimate and trusted partner and ally, the Jewish and democratic State of Israel, cannot be misconstrued for lack of trust or commitment to the United States,” the resolution reads. It also states that the House “rejects hate, discrimination, and antisemitism in all forms, including antisemitism masquerading as anti-Israel sentiment,” a frequent point of controversy in debates over Israel.
Trope trouble: The resolution further addresses conspiracy theories about Jewish control over the media and politics, as well as dual loyalty accusations faced by American Jews, which Omar has been accused of employing in the past. It notes that “Jewish Americans face rampant antisemitism in various forms” including “age-old tropes such as controlling the government and the media, [wielding] too much influence in decision-making bodies, seeking political, financial, and global dominance in society, and as greedy ‘money-hungry’ people” and “have also been accused of being more loyal to Israel than to the United States.”
Step forward: Gottheimer said in a statement, “For some time now, I have had an open, often emotional, sometimes pointed, and always honest dialogue with U.S. Congresswoman Ilhan Omar.” He called Omar’s cosponsorship of the resolution “an enormous step forward,” and said that it will “reinforce to people across our country, especially the scores of young people who look up to Congresswoman Omar, the importance of rejecting reflexive antisemitism and historic tropes, and seeing Israel as a key, historic, democratic ally of the United States.”
Omar explanation: Omar spokesperson Jeremy Slevin said in a statement to JI on Thursday, “The resolution Rep. Omar signed onto is about acknowledging hate and discrimination faced by marginalized communities in the United States throughout its history, including the Jewish community. She believes that as religious minorities we must work together to condemn this ancient hatred. As she said in her speech today [on the House floor], she will continue to stand for human rights around the world.”