WINEP’s David Makovsky noted Trump’s endorsement has not boosted Netanyahu in the polls
(Ohad Zwigenberg / POOL / AFP via Getty Images)
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu casts his ballot at his party Likud's main polling station during primary elections ahead of Israel's general election in October in Jerusalem on August 17, 2026.
Middle East policy experts offered differing assessments on Thursday of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s prospects in next week’s election, with some suggesting his political experience could carry him to another victory despite unfavorable polling, while others warned that neither his coalition nor the opposition may secure enough seats to form a government.
Speaking at the Hudson Institute in Washington ahead of Israel’s Oct. 27 election — the country’s first since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist attacks — David Makovsky, the Ziegler distinguished fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy; Michael Doran, a senior fellow and director of the Center for Peace and Security in the Middle East at Hudson; and David Wurmser, a senior analyst for Middle East affairs at the Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, examined the political divisions and security concerns shaping the race. The discussion was moderated by Hudson senior fellow Ludovic Hood.
Makovsky said the opposition bloc led by former IDF Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot has maintained a lead of roughly four or five seats in most polls, but neither side currently appears positioned to secure the 61 seats needed for a majority in Israel’s 120-member Knesset.
With smaller parties potentially determining the outcome, Makovsky suggested Netanyahu could remain in office even without securing a majority.
“I think that’s the zone we’re in: a minority government of full rights that has legal authority but doesn’t have political durability versus a caretaker government, and that seems to be Netanyahu’s strategy,” Makovsky said. “I don’t have to win this election; I just have to block you from winning.”
Makovsky also noted that President Donald Trump’s endorsement of Netanyahu over the weekend had not produced an apparent boost in recent polling, despite the prime minister’s hopes that American support would strengthen his electoral position.
Doran questioned, however, whether polls showing an opposition advantage accurately reflect the electorate, arguing that Israeli media outlets sympathetic to different political camps have produced sharply divergent projections.
“I don’t believe any of the polling,” Doran said. “If you look at the polls coming out of the mainstream media … they have Eisenkot winning … and then if you look at Channel 14, the Fox News equivalent [in Israel], Netanyahu is gonna win by a clear majority.”
Wurmser said the election also reflects a broader shift in Israeli political attitudes following years of war.
“Israel’s political spectrum has shifted rightward. It hasn’t translated into an electoral shift because the left parties have shifted rightward to some extent,” Wurmser said. “The points of view on the right side of the spectrum and the left side of the spectrum are to the right of where they were four years ago for obvious reasons.”
He said the continued exemption of Haredi men from military service is a source of frustration among Israelis serving extended periods in the reserves, and has also fueled tensions between ultra-Orthodox and national-religious communities.
“The second thing on people’s minds is they want the wars over, but they want [Israel] to win,” Wurmser said. “They don’t want to just give up. They want to go all the way, and there is frustration, and I think Netanyahu has been hurt by these ceasefires.”
The panelists also differed over whether Netanyahu’s wartime leadership has positioned Israel to capitalize on its military successes diplomatically. Makovsky argued that the prime minister has struggled to strengthen relationships with regional leaders despite Israel’s military achievements.
Doran argued that Netanyahu’s political experience and leadership during the war could prove decisive, even as the opposition seeks to hold him accountable for the security failures leading up to the Oct. 7 attacks.
“This is an election about Netanyahu,” Doran said. “For a lot of Israelis, it’s Netanyahu or anybody but Netanyahu.”
Doran acknowledged that some Netanyahu supporters hold him partially responsible, while arguing that he remains more politically capable than his rivals. “He is more talented, more experienced than anyone else on the Israeli stage,” Doran said.
“He’s the most influential prime minister of the last 20 years, or single most influential Israeli of the last 20 years, either the most influential or the second-most influential prime minister in Israel’s history,” Doran said. “But when it comes down to it, people look and they see Netanyahu is one of the most talented politicians on the global stage, not just in Israel.”
Makovsky said Israel’s military successes needed to be converted into political gains, recounting an analogy he said an Arab interlocutor had used: “At a certain point, you have to cash in your chips because if you don’t cash in the chips, the chips are worthless,” he said.
He suggested an Eisenkot-led government could take several relatively straightforward steps that the Netanyahu government has not to improve Israel’s diplomatic standing, including stronger action against violence by Israeli settlers in the West Bank.
“There are things he can do that are low-hanging fruit that, in my view, will change things,” Makovsky said. “For example, getting a police minister to deal with the lawlessness in the West Bank and saying, if you burn a home of a Palestinian, you go to jail, and they will shut this down real fast.”
He also argued that renewed engagement with the Palestinian Authority could help advance normalization with Saudi Arabia without requiring Israel to immediately pursue a two-state solution.
“We know Trump is desperate to [secure Saudi-Israel normalization], and MBS, [Crown Prince] Mohammed bin Salman of Saudi Arabia, wants to do it, but they need some political cover of some dialogue with the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank,” Makovsky said. “But the point is, it could change the view of Israel. It would stop the bleeding first of all in [the U.S.]. I’m talking about the public standing.”
Makovsky further suggested Eisenkot would seek greater cooperation with the Trump administration over Gaza, including an Egyptian effort to train Palestinian police as part of efforts to demilitarize Hamas. He said Israel would pull back from the enclave only if that effort succeeded.
“I think working with the Trump administration on that is something Eisenkot will try to do,” Makovsky said. “I think he will try to look for common cause.”
Meanwhile, Doran disputed the idea that changes in Israeli leadership or policy would substantially improve Western public opinion, “because a lot of Western public opinion is baked in because of Western ideologies that really have nothing to do with Israel.”
He also argued that Israeli opposition to a two-state solution has become deeply entrenched across much of the political spectrum, limiting the prospects for a major policy shift regardless of who wins.
As the discussion concluded, the panelists offered their predictions for the election, with Makovsky suggesting that neither bloc would secure an outright victory.
“I think the [likely outcome] is … the minority government, caretaker government … No one wins outright, and it is possible that there could be another election within the next year,” Makovsky said.
Wurmser was somewhat more optimistic about Netanyahu’s chances but acknowledged that obstacles still remain.
“My prediction is, I think the right will still squeak through enough to block a left-wing government, possibly to form a coalition,” Wurmser said. “But I think we’re also looking quite possibly at new elections in a few months because it will be difficult for Bibi to form a coalition cleanly.”
Doran, meanwhile, offered the most definitive prediction.
“Netanyahu by a nose,” he said.
‘Syria’s a pretty complicated mess, currently,’ Sen. James Lankford said. ‘They’ve still got to deal with ISIS’ presence there and the Syrian refugees in Lebanon need to return back to Syria.’
Marwan Naamani/picture alliance via Getty Images
Pro-Iranian Hezbollah supporters wave the party flags during a ceremony in a southern Beirut suburb on May 5, 2026.
Senators and Middle East policy experts expressed skepticism regarding President Donald Trump’s suggestion on Tuesday that Syria, rather than Israel, should handle the task of combating Hezbollah in Lebanon, following the president’s strident criticism of Israel’s attacks on the Iranian-backed terrorist group.
Trump said on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Évian-les-Bains. France, that Israel’s operations in Lebanon had moved too slowly and had been “vicious.” “I suggested to Israel to let Syria take care of Hezbollah, because to be honest with you, I think they do a better job of doing it,” Trump said.
“Syria’s a pretty complicated mess, currently,” Sen. James Lankford (R-OK) said. “They’ve still got to deal with ISIS’ presence there and the Syrian refugees in Lebanon need to return back to Syria. I think that’s the Syria connection there.”
Lankford said that he expected the Lebanese Armed Forces to say they would address the situation in Lebanon rather than bringing Syrian forces into the country. He added that Syria’s role should be limited to repatriating Syrians to Lebanon and eliminating ISIS in Syria as stabilization measures.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) dismissed the idea outright. “I have never heard that Syria is a viable opponent of Hezbollah,” Blumenthal said. “I heard him, literally, live talk about it, and it seems almost absurd to think of Syria as a viable opponent to Hezbollah.”
He also emphasized that “Hezbollah is attacking Israel, not Syria” and “Israel has to defend itself against Hezbollah. It can’t depend on Syria. In fact — it can’t depend on anyone exclusively. It has to defend itself against Hezbollah, and that’s just a fact of life.”
He said that the “solution” to achieve peace “is to stop Iran from supporting Hezbollah.”
“What?” a bewildered Sen. Chris Coons (D-DE) responded when asked by JI for his reaction to Trump’s suggestion.
“Yeah, sure,” Coons added. He then put his hands over his face and sighed before saying in an exasperated tone: “Oh my god.”
Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) also appeared to dismiss the idea, indicating that he was confused by Trump’s comments, telling JI: “I didn’t understand that.”
Sen. Pete Ricketts (R-NE) was largely noncommittal on the viability of Trump’s proposal, saying, “If Syria would go after Hezbollah, that would be a great thing.”
Middle East policy experts also expressed concern over Trump’s notion that Syria could play a “better” role in confronting Hezbollah than Israel, asserting that Damascus does not have the ability to take on such a task.
“The president’s remarks unfortunately show his complete lack of familiarity with Lebanon and Syria,” Elliott Abrams, former Iran envoy under the first Trump administration, told JI. “Syrian troops entered Lebanon in 1976 and did not withdraw until 2005. While they dominated Lebanon they killed something like 60,000 Lebanese. To suggest the return of Syrian forces to Lebanon is absurd and would instantly be rejected by all Lebanese.”
David Daoud, a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, similarly criticized the statement, saying it is important to “distinguish the rhetoric from what’s realistic.”
“Syria today does not have the capability nor the will to occupy Lebanon, which is what would be necessary to dismantle Hezbollah,” Daoud said. “Their country has just emerged from a 14-year devastating civil war, they’re economically broke, they’re just starting to reintegrate into the international community.”
He said that such actions would go beyond the responsibilities that the Syrian people expect from Al-Sharaa’s new transitional government.
“The mandate that the Syrian people have given him is ‘Rebuild our country, give us a normal life, we don’t want wars, we don’t want expansionism,’” Daoud explained. “So there’s that element. If they go too far, they end up like [former Syrian President Bashar] al-Assad.”
Yoni Tobin, a senior policy analyst at the Jewish Institute for National Security of America, said the idea that Syria would be better-equipped to take on Hezbollah than Israel “is a fanciful one.”
“Israel has spent decades successfully fighting against, studying, and penetrating Hezbollah, and has eliminated thousands of its field operatives and missile sites,” Tobin said. “When’s the last time, for example, that Syria detonated several thousand Hezbollah walkie-talkies at once?”
Tobin warned that the prospect of Syrian forces entering Lebanon would be “dangerous” and could threaten U.S. and Israeli security interests. He noted that al-Sharaa’s close ties with Turkey are particularly alarming.
“Even if Syrian forces were to somehow succeed at disarming Hezbollah, that would only replace an Iranian sphere of influence on Israel’s northern border with – yet another – Turkish one,” Tobin said. “That prospect alone should alarm Washington.”
Former U.S. Ambassador to Israel Daniel Shapiro suggested that allowing Syrian forces to confront Hezbollah could “unify the Lebanese against that irresponsible proposal.”
“It recalls previous episodes of Syrian occupation, and could unleash violence across the country,” Shapiro said. “What the Syrian government can do is work to shut down smuggling networks across the porous Syrian-Lebanese border, which could deprive Hezbollah of the ability to resupply its weapons.”
Analysts also dismissed Trump’s criticism of Israeli operations in Lebanon.
“Trump’s criticism of Israel for fighting back against Hezbollah is equally wrong,” Abrams said. “Israel’s strike killed Ali Musa Daqduq, who was a Hezbollah terrorist who led the kidnapping and murder of five American soldiers in 2007. The president should be thanking Israel for that — and he should not be making light of drone strikes as ‘a minor little thing.’”
Daoud said that while individual Israeli military actions in Lebanon may have “crossed the line” and are open to criticism, he “totally disagrees” with Trump’s claim and pressure on Israel.
“I think President Trump is framing it in that way because this is undermining his desire for a deal,” Daoud said, arguing that criticism and pressure should instead be directed toward Lebanon.
Daoud said that Hezbollah retains “massive and overwhelming” support from the Lebanese public, adding that Beirut remains “unwilling and unable to deal with Hezbollah properly.”
“I reject this narrative that the Trump administration is trying to promote, which is that Lebanon is not the problem, Hezbollah is the problem, Hezbollah is the enemy of Lebanon,” he added. “This is fiction. I reject the nonsense that Hezbollah is an Iranian occupation of Lebanon. Hezbollah is part of the government…they are in parliament, they are Lebanese.”
Please log in if you already have a subscription, or subscribe to access the latest updates.


































































Continue with Google
Continue with Apple